Thursday, February 8, 2007

L.A Question

The question: Ernest Hemingway's experiences in World War 1 changed him forever. How did those experiences affect his writing?
Ernest Hemingway was a volunteer ambulance driver. He was injured by shrapnel from a bomb, and was sent home. He probably saw horrible things that he could never forget. This affected his writing by making it less happy and more (from my point of view) hopeless. By that I don't mean that he was a bad writer, he was quite famous, but I mean that of the stories that I've read (one), they do not have victorious endings, but instead, endings with defeat. Although that's not really the way to describe it either, because as Santiago says in "The Old Man and the Sea", "Man was not made for defeat. You can destroy a man, but not defeat him." I guess his writing is more about not trying to do more than you can handle, and that you need pride, but you can't live with it either.
Many people remember Hemingway being happier and funnier before the war, but, as war often does, he lost his sense of humor and hapiness after seeing all those horrible things. I think that if Hemingway had not been in the war, his novels would end in victory and he might have a bit of humor here and there as well.

10 comments:

Anna-bug said...

Yes, I agree with you Laura. And I wonder if he would have even written some of his books if he hadn't been in the war. He might have written stories that had nothing to do with what he wrote about toward the end of his life. good observations, Laura!

Chan said...

Yes, I also agree Anna, I think that he should have experienced many horrible things,,,

Anyway, visit MINE!!!

Chan

^^

Anna-bug said...

It is really sad how all these writers were pretty messed up, yet they wrote so many amazing books. It is so sad!

Anonymous said...

I agree with Laura(and Anna and Chan.

Stephanie said...

Mrs. Koning told us a lot about his life and the world war and how it affected him. It's actually really sad!!!!!! So many were affected and changed for life. That's probably the reason his works are sad but yet still very deep. I wonder if his books would have been happier if he hadn't experienced it all, and yet his sad books were really what people needed to here as they themselves had experienced it too.

laura said...

Do you think that Hemingway would have been famous if he hadn't been in the war?

Sacha said...

Well it's really good and I agree, but maybe don't write to much next time

Medhive said...

Nice long post, good job.

Koko said...

I feel really sorry for him! Aren't we so incredibly lucky not to live through those times! And it was so recent, yet it seems so far in the past. The war definately effected EH's writing! Its more depressing...
Koko

Josiah said...

It made Earnest hemingway write about hardshps and how people had to struggle through them